I have now managed to obtain a copy of the book by Jim Al-Khalili and Johnjoe McFadden. Understandably, it goes into more details than the TV documentary. I am about halfway through the book. It's fascinating. So far, I have read about: a discussion of Schroedinger's original ideas about Life in which he contrasted QM (at the microscopic level) with thermodynamics (at the classical level). He talked about the interplay of Order and Chaos.
Also, the book talks in detail about the action of enzymes, especially on proteins, and how this action is greatly sped up by quantum tunnelling. The authors giving the charming example of how a tadpole turns into a frog. It loses its tail in the process.
The next chapter talks about photosynthesis in the leaves of green plants. Interestingly, it gives an estimate of the "decoherence time" as roughly 1 picosecond. There is a quasiparticle called an "exciton" which consists of an electron and a hole (the gap left when an electron leaves an atom). The exciton traverses many paths simultaneously, in order to find the quickest path to a molecule, possibly ADP (adenosyne triphosphate). Using the classical approach, this could only be done in exponential time, but thanks to quantum parallelism, it can be done in polynomial time. I find the connections with Critical Path Analysis most fascinating.
The following chapter talks about the sense of smell, which is transmitted by olfactory molecules. There is a special membrane in the nose, containing olfactory neurons that distinguish the different molecules, not by shape, but by the vibrational frequency of the constituent atoms. In fact, molecules will very similar shapes can have completely different smells. Moreoever, some molecules with totally different shapes can smell almost exactly the same. The nose "hears" the frequency of the atom, thanks to QM.
In the chapter on the Mind, there is a discussion of the Penrose/Hameroff theory. Unfortunately, Jim Al-Khalili and Mr McFadden pretty much reject this theory! Their basic reason is that the quantum coherence of the microtubules across regions of the cerebral cortex would supposedly decohere too quickly. They cite the infamous paper by Max Tegmark. However, Hameroff has already refuted the mistakes in this paper. Basically, Tegmark oversimplifies the structure of the microtubules, by saying they are linear, when they are actually cylindrical. The structure of the microtubule protects it from decoherence. So does the "ordered water" surrounding it.
They slightly mispresent Penrose's ideas. According to them, Penrose has said that the brain (and each microtubule) is a quantum computer. However, in terms of its ability to answer mathematical questions a quantum computer is only equivalent to a Turing machine (and therefore, it would not be able to perceive the truth of a Goedel sentence). In fact, Penrose has claimed that the mind is a non-computable quantum system, harnessing some non-computable physics which has not yet been discovered. He has claimed this will be embodied in the correct version of quantum gravity. When the wavefunction collapses (decoheres), it does so according to QM (Quantum Gravity), which is based on non-computable mathematics. Each such collapse is a conscious event.
Also, they say that a computer would be able to generate a statement whose truth could not be ascertained by a human. This is completely and totally wrong! A computer works by an algorithm, which can be translated into a formal system F and then its Goedel sentence G(F) can be generated, and the human would indeed be able to perceive the truth of G(F).
These are very subtle points, but it's a shame that Penrose and Hameroff were not properly represented.
Apart from this, the "Life on the Edge Book" by Al-Khalili and McFadden is excellent, and I really admire what they have done. I hope there is a lot more research into the brand new field of Quantum Biology. Who knows what more strange discoveries will be made in the future?
Postscript: I have just remembered something important: Some empirical evidence for the Penrose/Hameroff theory has been discovered in 2013/2014. The experiments were carried out in Japan, by a team of researchers. There is indeed quantum coherence in microtubules, even at body temperature.
Postscript 2: I have read some more of "Life on the Edge", which (on the whole) is excellent. The chapter about the sense of smell is interesting. Some olfactory molecules are mirror images of each other, but smell completely different. As far as I know, there is no theory explaining this, as yet. However, for other olfactory molecules, it comes down to the vibration frequency of the bonds between atoms, such as hydrogen-sulphur. Putting the different frequencies into order, this give a kind of "spectrum" of frequencies. Different bands correspond to different smells.
No comments:
Post a Comment