A few years ago, two physicists, called Elitzur and Vaidman, proposed an idea called the Bomb-Testing Paradox. Suppose that you have a number of bombs. Some are real and some are broken. The broken ones will never explode, not even if you press the detonator. Of course, the real ones will explode. From the point of view of classical physics, the only way of knowing which ones are real and which are broken, is to press the detonators. However, this will destroy all the working bombs, which defeats the purpose of the exercise.
The extraordinary thing is that by using quantum physics, we can determine which bombs are real, without destroying all of them! We start by the setting up the equipment as in the diagram below:
A is a photon source. The bomb is situated at B. C and D are photon detectors. The photo is emitted by A and passes through a half-silvered mirror. It is now in a superposition of states: one state moving right and one state moving up. The state moving right passes by the bomb at B. The two states bounce off mirrors and recombine at the top-right corner, which is another half-silvered mirror. The wavelike interference is either constructive or destructive. Depending on this, the photon will be detected at either C or D. When the photon reaches the detectors, measurements are made, and so the wavefunction collapses. Then, the photon is either in one state or the other.
If the bomb is broken, obviously it does not explode. D detects a photon and C does not.
If the bomb works, then the wavefunction collapses when the photon passes by it, because quantum effects have influenced an object at the classical level. The photon is either located on the lower side of the square or the left side of the square. If it's located on the lower side of the square, the bomb explodes. We know that it's a working bomb!
If the photon is located on the left side, it bounces off the mirror, moves right, gets split into two by the half-silvered mirror, and then, in its superposed state enters the detectors C or D. The wavefunction collapses for a second time, and the photon is detected at either C or D, but not both.
So, in conclusion, if the bomb explodes, then it is working (or was working until it destroyed itself). If the photon is detected at D, then the bomb is working. If the photon is detected at C, the bomb may or may not be working, but we do not know which is the case.
This is interesting from a philosophical point of view, because it involves the idea of counterfactuals: events which could have happened but did not: the bomb could have exploded but did not. Even though the event did not happen, it still influenced other events: it caused the photon to be detected at D (at least 50% of the time). This is very strange from a common-sense, classical-physics point of view. Surely, only events that have actually happened can influence future events. If an event did not happen (but could have), how can it influence future events? This is the nature of the paradox.
Counterfactual conditionals have been extensively analysed by philosophers. There is an article here:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Counterfactual_conditional
I would like to add that there is a slight problem with the experiment. There is a 25% chance of the bomb exploding. But if just one bomb explodes, it will destroy all the apparatus: half-silvered mirrors, photon detectors and all. Perhaps it would be better to use the apparatus to test some other kind of device, which is less dangerous.
Relating to consciousness, Roger Penrose has suggested that something like this might be happening inside the brain. I guess that instead of photons and half-silvered mirrors, you would have microtubules, conveying information, and instead of bombs and photon detectors causing the wavefunction to collapse, you would have neurons firing. (It's a good thing we don't have bombs exploding inside our brains!)
If anyone reading this can think of a way to elaborate upon this, I would love to hear your comments. Please post any comments below. Thanks! Goodbye for now!
Sunday, 21 July 2013
Monday, 8 July 2013
The Title of this Blog
As many of you will have noticed, the URL for this blog is quantumphylosophy etc, etc. Of course, I have spelt the word "philosophy" wrong. There is a very common-place reason for this. It is because the URL for quantumphilosophy had already been taken. I had to find a variation that was as close to the original as possible. I decided to spell "philosophy" with a Y, because then it would resemble "physics", and so there is a kind of double meaning: "physics and philosophy". (A portmanteau word...)
I do not have much time to write today, but I hope to write in more detail at a later time. I have just been reading chapters 7 and 8 of "Shadows of the Mind" by Roger Penrose, a book which I would heartily recommend to everyone! One of the most fascinating ideas is that of all the microtubules in the cerebrum getting entangled, and thus all the information being combined into a single quantum state.
Finally, I would like everyone reading this blog to post their feedback. Do you agree / disagree with what I am saying? Am I expressing myself clearly enough? How could this blog be improved? Thanks in advance.
I do not have much time to write today, but I hope to write in more detail at a later time. I have just been reading chapters 7 and 8 of "Shadows of the Mind" by Roger Penrose, a book which I would heartily recommend to everyone! One of the most fascinating ideas is that of all the microtubules in the cerebrum getting entangled, and thus all the information being combined into a single quantum state.
Finally, I would like everyone reading this blog to post their feedback. Do you agree / disagree with what I am saying? Am I expressing myself clearly enough? How could this blog be improved? Thanks in advance.
Sunday, 7 July 2013
The Perception of the Truth or Falsity of Statements
How are we able to perceive the truth of the Godel statement S, which says "Statement S cannot be proved within formal system F"? F is a formal system sufficiently advanced to incorporate the laws of arithmetic, such as the Zermelo-Fraenkel axioms or the Peano axioms.
The formal system is unable to prove it. A Turing machine could not prove it. So how are we able to perceive that it is true? We are able to look at the formal system from the outside, in a "metalinguistic" sense.
According to the Penrose-Hameroff theory, the mind is a quantum phenomenon, involving large-scale coherence of microtubules across the entire brain. How is this mind able to perceive the truth of statement S?
Let us consider the more general question of how it can perceive the truth of any statement. It holds an image of the statement in its mind. It considers whether the statement is grammatically correct, and if so, whether it is meaningful, and if so, whether it is true or false. A statement only has meaning within the context of a language or metalanguage. This could be a natural language such as English, or the abstract language of mathematics.
For a person to understand the meaning of a statement, he must relate the statement to his knowledge of the grammar and vocabulary of the language, which he must remember. Where in his mind does he remember all this? I would suggest that he remembers it in the microtubules. Each tubulin dimer can be in one of two basic states, but also in a superposition of states. I think this is how memories are stored in the brain. In this case, the memories are the knowledge of the grammar and vocabulary of the language, and also our concept of syntax, semantics and truth/falsity.
When a person thinks about a statement, all the microtubules in his brain are in a quantum coherent state, the Bose-Einstein condensate. This state can be described by a single wavefunction, and all the memories and ideas in the different microtubules come together into a single conscious experience. In this state, the person is able to perceive the statement within the context of the language, and ascertain its grammatical correctness, meaning and truth value (which could be true, false or meaningless). In the Godel statement S (above), he is able to perceive that it is true.
Only a quantum system can do this, because it can combine all this individual states together into a single coherent whole. This is called holism.
In a classical system, such as the mechanism as a clock, the constituent parts are separated out from each other, and only interact crudely via cause-and-effect (as opposed to the acausality inherent in quantum mechanics.) Any information stored in a clockwork mechanism always remains separated from the other information, and there is no possibility of combining all this information together.
This is how a person is able to perceive the truth of the Godel statement above. Anyone has the potential to do this if he or she tries hard enough, and I would encourage everyone reading this to get hold of two books by Roger Penrose: Emperor's New Mind and Shadows of the Mind, which explain the meaning of formal systems and Godel's two incompleteness theorems in more detail than I have given here.
The formal system is unable to prove it. A Turing machine could not prove it. So how are we able to perceive that it is true? We are able to look at the formal system from the outside, in a "metalinguistic" sense.
According to the Penrose-Hameroff theory, the mind is a quantum phenomenon, involving large-scale coherence of microtubules across the entire brain. How is this mind able to perceive the truth of statement S?
Let us consider the more general question of how it can perceive the truth of any statement. It holds an image of the statement in its mind. It considers whether the statement is grammatically correct, and if so, whether it is meaningful, and if so, whether it is true or false. A statement only has meaning within the context of a language or metalanguage. This could be a natural language such as English, or the abstract language of mathematics.
For a person to understand the meaning of a statement, he must relate the statement to his knowledge of the grammar and vocabulary of the language, which he must remember. Where in his mind does he remember all this? I would suggest that he remembers it in the microtubules. Each tubulin dimer can be in one of two basic states, but also in a superposition of states. I think this is how memories are stored in the brain. In this case, the memories are the knowledge of the grammar and vocabulary of the language, and also our concept of syntax, semantics and truth/falsity.
When a person thinks about a statement, all the microtubules in his brain are in a quantum coherent state, the Bose-Einstein condensate. This state can be described by a single wavefunction, and all the memories and ideas in the different microtubules come together into a single conscious experience. In this state, the person is able to perceive the statement within the context of the language, and ascertain its grammatical correctness, meaning and truth value (which could be true, false or meaningless). In the Godel statement S (above), he is able to perceive that it is true.
Only a quantum system can do this, because it can combine all this individual states together into a single coherent whole. This is called holism.
In a classical system, such as the mechanism as a clock, the constituent parts are separated out from each other, and only interact crudely via cause-and-effect (as opposed to the acausality inherent in quantum mechanics.) Any information stored in a clockwork mechanism always remains separated from the other information, and there is no possibility of combining all this information together.
This is how a person is able to perceive the truth of the Godel statement above. Anyone has the potential to do this if he or she tries hard enough, and I would encourage everyone reading this to get hold of two books by Roger Penrose: Emperor's New Mind and Shadows of the Mind, which explain the meaning of formal systems and Godel's two incompleteness theorems in more detail than I have given here.
Wednesday, 3 July 2013
The Hydrogen Atom
Classical physics fails to explain how the hydrogen atom can exist. This atom consists of an electron and a proton. According to the laws of classical physics, the electron and proton should be thought of as tiny "snooker balls" endowed with electric charge. The negative electron is attracted to the positive proton, an moves in a circular orbit around the proton. The trouble is, that it is accelerating (because it velocity vector is continuously changing over time), and so the electron radiates energy (light), and so it loses kinetic energy, and spirals in towards the proton. The electron merges with the proton, and they annihilate each other, possible creating light (photons). If this were true, all the hydrogen atoms would quickly cease to exist.
This catastrophic situation can be avoided by thinking of the electron (and the proton) in terms of a wave function. In fact, the electron is not localised at one point in space. It is spread out over a region, rather like a "gas" or a "magnetic field". The shapes of these regions are determined by solutions to the Schrodinger equation in three dimensions. Here is this equation in its most basic form:
where H = Hamiltonian operator,
i = square root of -1,
ħ = Planck's constant divided by 2π,
ψ = the wavefunction,
t = time
The H operator represents the amount of energy: kinetic plus potential. i, h and pi are just constants (of proportionality). The equation is saying that amount of energy is proportional to rate of change. The more energy the system has, the faster it will change.
The potential field that the electron finds itself in is a central force, probably operating in accordance with the inverse square law (as in classical electrostatics). The solutions are in the form of spherical harmonics. These are the "orbitals" of the electron which are given names like s, p, f and d.
I will write more about this topic another day.
This catastrophic situation can be avoided by thinking of the electron (and the proton) in terms of a wave function. In fact, the electron is not localised at one point in space. It is spread out over a region, rather like a "gas" or a "magnetic field". The shapes of these regions are determined by solutions to the Schrodinger equation in three dimensions. Here is this equation in its most basic form:
H ψ = i
ħ (∂ψ / ∂t)
where H = Hamiltonian operator,
i = square root of -1,
ħ = Planck's constant divided by 2π,
ψ = the wavefunction,
t = time
The H operator represents the amount of energy: kinetic plus potential. i, h and pi are just constants (of proportionality). The equation is saying that amount of energy is proportional to rate of change. The more energy the system has, the faster it will change.
The potential field that the electron finds itself in is a central force, probably operating in accordance with the inverse square law (as in classical electrostatics). The solutions are in the form of spherical harmonics. These are the "orbitals" of the electron which are given names like s, p, f and d.
I will write more about this topic another day.
Monday, 1 July 2013
First post on the blog
1st July 2013
I am starting a new blog about the relationship between philosophy and quantum mechanics. It will probably focus a great deal on consciousness, which some people believe is a quantum phenomenon. However, I shall not neglect the hydrogen atom, photosynthesis, superconductivity, the sense of smell and many other ideas and applications.
I should begin by saying a little about what quantum mechanics actually is. (I am basing this on the book Quantum Mechanics by Alistair Rae, which I am reading at the moment.)
Quantum mechanics is a branch of physics that deals with atomic processes, usually at very small levels. It explains the motions of electrons, protons and neutrons. This are all spin 1/2 particles, hence fermions. It turns out that their motions are non-deterministic, in contrast with the determinism of Newtonian physics. I shudder to think what Isaac Newton would have thought of quantum mechanics!
Another idea is the "wave/particle duality", which means that particles like electrons sometimes have wavelike behaviour (when they pass through a crystal lattice) and sometimes particle-like behaviour.
It is possible for two particles to be entangled, so that they are fundamentally described by the same wavefunction. In this situation, measuring one particle will affect the other, even if it's several light years away. This is called non-locality. If many particles (say one million) become entangled, and are in a similar (but not identical) state, this is called coherence. Examples include the Bose-Einstein condensate, and superfluids, such as liquid helium.
Quantum mechanics explains a wide range of phenomena, including atoms and how they react with each other to form molecules. All the chemical reactions in a cell's metabolism are quantum. It explains the scattering of light from oxygen molecules that makes the sky blue. It explains light and the double slit experiment. There are several technologies based on QM: lasers, semiconductors which leads to silicon chips and computers, MRI scans used in hospitals to "see inside" a patient's head.
Future applications may even include teleportation and quantum computers and cryptography. However, there are some limits, because it has been proved mathematically that you cannot use QM for cloning. (Only biological cloning is possible, and this is done in an entirely different way.)
I should also like to talk about the Penrose-Hameroff theory of consciousness, which says that consciousness is due to microtubules in neurons. The microtubules become entangled into a quantum state throughout the brain, and all the sensations are put together into a single unified experience. This solves the binding problem (How can the radically different sensations from the five senses be combined into a single conscious experience?). Microtubules are shaped like cylinders, and are a bit like polymers but not necessarily repeating. They consist of two different types of tubulin: alpha and beta. According two the theory, the different states (alpha and beta) contain the "information" that makes up our conscious experience.
In my opinion, QM allows for free will, because the collapse of the wavefunction is nondeterministic, and this is where people freely make their choices between several different possibilities. There is clearly no room for free will in Newtonian physics. QM is a much more likely candidate.
I hope to expand on these points in subsequent posts on the blog.
I am starting a new blog about the relationship between philosophy and quantum mechanics. It will probably focus a great deal on consciousness, which some people believe is a quantum phenomenon. However, I shall not neglect the hydrogen atom, photosynthesis, superconductivity, the sense of smell and many other ideas and applications.
I should begin by saying a little about what quantum mechanics actually is. (I am basing this on the book Quantum Mechanics by Alistair Rae, which I am reading at the moment.)
Quantum mechanics is a branch of physics that deals with atomic processes, usually at very small levels. It explains the motions of electrons, protons and neutrons. This are all spin 1/2 particles, hence fermions. It turns out that their motions are non-deterministic, in contrast with the determinism of Newtonian physics. I shudder to think what Isaac Newton would have thought of quantum mechanics!
Another idea is the "wave/particle duality", which means that particles like electrons sometimes have wavelike behaviour (when they pass through a crystal lattice) and sometimes particle-like behaviour.
It is possible for two particles to be entangled, so that they are fundamentally described by the same wavefunction. In this situation, measuring one particle will affect the other, even if it's several light years away. This is called non-locality. If many particles (say one million) become entangled, and are in a similar (but not identical) state, this is called coherence. Examples include the Bose-Einstein condensate, and superfluids, such as liquid helium.
Quantum mechanics explains a wide range of phenomena, including atoms and how they react with each other to form molecules. All the chemical reactions in a cell's metabolism are quantum. It explains the scattering of light from oxygen molecules that makes the sky blue. It explains light and the double slit experiment. There are several technologies based on QM: lasers, semiconductors which leads to silicon chips and computers, MRI scans used in hospitals to "see inside" a patient's head.
Future applications may even include teleportation and quantum computers and cryptography. However, there are some limits, because it has been proved mathematically that you cannot use QM for cloning. (Only biological cloning is possible, and this is done in an entirely different way.)
I should also like to talk about the Penrose-Hameroff theory of consciousness, which says that consciousness is due to microtubules in neurons. The microtubules become entangled into a quantum state throughout the brain, and all the sensations are put together into a single unified experience. This solves the binding problem (How can the radically different sensations from the five senses be combined into a single conscious experience?). Microtubules are shaped like cylinders, and are a bit like polymers but not necessarily repeating. They consist of two different types of tubulin: alpha and beta. According two the theory, the different states (alpha and beta) contain the "information" that makes up our conscious experience.
In my opinion, QM allows for free will, because the collapse of the wavefunction is nondeterministic, and this is where people freely make their choices between several different possibilities. There is clearly no room for free will in Newtonian physics. QM is a much more likely candidate.
I hope to expand on these points in subsequent posts on the blog.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
