The other day, I was fortunate enough to watch a fascinating documentary about the new science of Quantum Biology. It was presented very enthusiastically by Jim al-Khalili, who is a physicist. (He has collaborated with a biologist called John Joe McFadden.)
He gave several examples of where quantum mechanics is used by Nature in living organisms:
(1) Robins use the Earth's magnetic field to fly south in the winter. (Harnessing the EPR paradox. The robin's magnetic sense works like an inclination compass. It has a molecule called cryptochrome in its retina.)
(2) Photosynthesis (quasiparticles, such as "excitons" move through every possible path simultaneously. Linear superposition of states.)
(3) The sense of smell (depends on the vibration of atoms, rather than the shape of molecules)
(4) Tadpole transforming into frog (enzymes use quantum physics to speed up chemical reactions, making them millions of times faster. Quantum tunnelling.)
(5) The evolution of life. (When DNA molecules are copied, there are random quantum effects, which lead to mutations in the sequence of bases, eg, ACGT mutates into ACGA. This is the ultimate reason for variations in species and hence evolution.)
Examples (1) and (3) are related to consciousness. The robin can perceive the Earth's very weak magnetic field. Humans and many animals (such as dogs) can perceive smells, via molecules that disperse through the air.
People have been suggesting that QM has a role to play in living organisms since about 1944, when Erwin Schrodinger wrote his classic book "What is Life?" Of course, the Penrose/Hameroff theory depends on quantum effects happening in microtubules in the brain.
At the moment, there seems to be a lot of scepticism that QM has a role in biology. This is most unfortunate. However, Jim al-Khalili and his colleagues (such as John Joe McFadden) have now provided us with empirical evidence to support their findings. I hope that this will be regarded fairly and open-mindedly by other scientists, and that more people will take an interest in researching quantum biology.
Unfortunately, Jim al-Khalili did not mention the Penrose/Hameroff theory in his TV documentary. Perhaps there was not enough time, in the 60 minutes available. However, recently (c. 2013-2014), there have been experiments carried out in Japan, which show quantum effects are happening in microtubules, at body temperature, i.e., 36.5 to 37.5 °C. (In fact, when you have a fever or hyperthermia you are still conscious, and so the effects should still happen at higher temperatures, e.g., from 38 to 41.5 degrees C.)
I hope that the initial success of these results will encourage more research into the Penrose/Hameroff theory. The more empirical evidence is found, the more that people will begin to take it seriously. Also, it helps to discover the finer points: exactly what kind of quantum effects are at work, and how exactly they relate to consciousness.
Jim al-Khalili and John Joe McFadden have together published a book: "Life on the Edge: The Coming Age of Quantum Biology". This is published by Bantam Press and is about 360 pages long. Unfortunately, I have not had time to read it yet!
I hope to write about this subject again soon.
Friday, 26 December 2014
Sunday, 5 October 2014
The Quantum Self
In the early 1990s, Danah Zohar wrote an excellent book called the Quantum Self. Combining physics, psychology and philosophy, it proposes a theory of consciousness based on Bose-Einstein condensates (BEC) appearing in the brain. These are very specific forms of condensed matter, in which quantum effects begin to happen over a macroscopic region, in this case, over a distance of about 10 cm, the average diameter of the brain. This theory is based upon earlier ideas from Herbert Frohlich, and Danah has developed it further in collobration with her husband, Ian Marshall.
The various neurons interact by exchanging (virtual) photons, until the cell walls of the neurons begin to vibrate at the same frequency, about 10^11 Hz. The photons, as we know, are bosons, having spin 0. They obey Bose-Einstein statistics. It is these bosons that form the BEC. This has a unifying effect, because all the neurons become one single unified entity. This accounts for the oneness of consciousness: the five senses are experienced as one single unified experience. (This has been noticed by many people, including Immanuel Kant.) This is the solution to the binding problem.
The BEC has a ground state (its lowest energy state) and this is when a person has a minimum level of consciousness. Perhaps he is just on the brink of waking up from a deep sleep, and cannot yet see or hear things. As sense-impressions gradually form upon this "blank state", the BEC gradually moves up to higher energy state. Waves form across it like ripples on a tranquil pond. The waves correspond to the sense-impressions. It is possible for the body and brain to maintain the BEC, even at body temperature, 37 degrees C, as Frohlich was able to demonstrate. As long as all the relevant neurons keep oscillating at the same frequency, the correct state is maintained. When the person falls asleep, the BEC disintegrates, consciousness is lost, and the subject falls into a dreamless sleep.
The brilliance of Danah Zohar's book is that she is able to relate all of this to psychology. For example, she proposes that people are like waves, and relationships between people are like overlapping waves. She even goes further than this and talks about the possibility of life after death, and the idea of "God within ourselves". This is connected to shamanism and the effects of certain drug: entheogens, such as mescaline which comes from the peyote cactus. Entheogens allow people to find God within themselves.
As the title of the book implies, some the discussion is about the self and self-identity: the old philosophical question of how a person can change so much over time, and yet still be the same person. Aristotle suggests that a person (or even an inanimate object) has the potential to change, and then actualises the potential. Also, many references to philosophers, thinkers and mystics such as Heraclitus, Parmenides, Carl Gustav Jung, Teilhard de Chardin, and Rainer Maria Rilke. It is very encouraging to see their ideas and visions being incorporated into a new theory of psychology.
This is an excellent book, as I have said, but unfortunately, it is out of print! You can buy a copy from ABE Books, a second-hand book website. Apart from anything else, I hope that a publisher will bring this book back into print again!
The various neurons interact by exchanging (virtual) photons, until the cell walls of the neurons begin to vibrate at the same frequency, about 10^11 Hz. The photons, as we know, are bosons, having spin 0. They obey Bose-Einstein statistics. It is these bosons that form the BEC. This has a unifying effect, because all the neurons become one single unified entity. This accounts for the oneness of consciousness: the five senses are experienced as one single unified experience. (This has been noticed by many people, including Immanuel Kant.) This is the solution to the binding problem.
The BEC has a ground state (its lowest energy state) and this is when a person has a minimum level of consciousness. Perhaps he is just on the brink of waking up from a deep sleep, and cannot yet see or hear things. As sense-impressions gradually form upon this "blank state", the BEC gradually moves up to higher energy state. Waves form across it like ripples on a tranquil pond. The waves correspond to the sense-impressions. It is possible for the body and brain to maintain the BEC, even at body temperature, 37 degrees C, as Frohlich was able to demonstrate. As long as all the relevant neurons keep oscillating at the same frequency, the correct state is maintained. When the person falls asleep, the BEC disintegrates, consciousness is lost, and the subject falls into a dreamless sleep.
The brilliance of Danah Zohar's book is that she is able to relate all of this to psychology. For example, she proposes that people are like waves, and relationships between people are like overlapping waves. She even goes further than this and talks about the possibility of life after death, and the idea of "God within ourselves". This is connected to shamanism and the effects of certain drug: entheogens, such as mescaline which comes from the peyote cactus. Entheogens allow people to find God within themselves.
As the title of the book implies, some the discussion is about the self and self-identity: the old philosophical question of how a person can change so much over time, and yet still be the same person. Aristotle suggests that a person (or even an inanimate object) has the potential to change, and then actualises the potential. Also, many references to philosophers, thinkers and mystics such as Heraclitus, Parmenides, Carl Gustav Jung, Teilhard de Chardin, and Rainer Maria Rilke. It is very encouraging to see their ideas and visions being incorporated into a new theory of psychology.
This is an excellent book, as I have said, but unfortunately, it is out of print! You can buy a copy from ABE Books, a second-hand book website. Apart from anything else, I hope that a publisher will bring this book back into print again!
Saturday, 2 August 2014
Carl Jung and Wolfgang Pauli
Carl Gustav Jung was an eminent psychiatrist with some quite controversial ideas. Wolfgang Pauli was an eminent physicist, who worked on quantum mechanics. He is famous for the Pauli exclusion principle, which states that two fermions cannot be in the same state at the same time.
At one point in his life, Pauli had a kind of nervous breakdown. His father had an affair. His mother found out and was so upset that she committed suicide. Pauli was naturally very upset by this. He started to go to cabaret shows, and ended up marrying a cabaret singer. After about a year they got divorced, and Pauli was even more upset! Someone suggested to him that he go for therapy. By coincidence (or synchronicity?) he was at the same uni as Carl Jung and they met.
Jung was fascinated by Pauli's dreams, because they were full of symbols from alchemy, even though Pauli had never studied this. Jung thought it would be fruitful for Pauli to be analysed, but was worried that he might superimpose or transfer his own ideas onto him, so he assigned a younger psychiatrist with the task. She analysed about 400 of Pauli's dreams and passed on the results to Jung.
If I am not mistaken, Jung published his analysis in Psychology and Alchemy, which can also be found in a book called simply Dreams, published by Routledge.
Jung and Pauli developed a close friendship, exchanged many letters, and talked about the similarities between psychology and quantum mechanics. For example, in quantum mechanics, there is the idea of non-locality, exemplified by the EPR paradox, in which two electrons become entangled and fly apart. Eventually, they get very far apart, and then a scientist measures one of them. It causes the other electron to collapse down to a definite state. There is a kind of "action at a distance".
This is similar to the Jungian notion of synchronicity, in which two events happens simultaneously, even though there is no cause and effect relationship.
Jung also liked the idea of pairs of complementary quantities, eg,
Position and momentum
Energy and time
Famously, in quantum mechanics, the observer affects the experiment. You cannot observe an atom, without collapsing its wave function. Something similar is true in psychotherapy. The therapists affects the patient. There is sometimes transference and counter-transference.
At one point in his life, Pauli had a kind of nervous breakdown. His father had an affair. His mother found out and was so upset that she committed suicide. Pauli was naturally very upset by this. He started to go to cabaret shows, and ended up marrying a cabaret singer. After about a year they got divorced, and Pauli was even more upset! Someone suggested to him that he go for therapy. By coincidence (or synchronicity?) he was at the same uni as Carl Jung and they met.
Jung was fascinated by Pauli's dreams, because they were full of symbols from alchemy, even though Pauli had never studied this. Jung thought it would be fruitful for Pauli to be analysed, but was worried that he might superimpose or transfer his own ideas onto him, so he assigned a younger psychiatrist with the task. She analysed about 400 of Pauli's dreams and passed on the results to Jung.
If I am not mistaken, Jung published his analysis in Psychology and Alchemy, which can also be found in a book called simply Dreams, published by Routledge.
Jung and Pauli developed a close friendship, exchanged many letters, and talked about the similarities between psychology and quantum mechanics. For example, in quantum mechanics, there is the idea of non-locality, exemplified by the EPR paradox, in which two electrons become entangled and fly apart. Eventually, they get very far apart, and then a scientist measures one of them. It causes the other electron to collapse down to a definite state. There is a kind of "action at a distance".
This is similar to the Jungian notion of synchronicity, in which two events happens simultaneously, even though there is no cause and effect relationship.
Jung also liked the idea of pairs of complementary quantities, eg,
Position and momentum
Energy and time
Famously, in quantum mechanics, the observer affects the experiment. You cannot observe an atom, without collapsing its wave function. Something similar is true in psychotherapy. The therapists affects the patient. There is sometimes transference and counter-transference.
Thursday, 3 July 2014
The Growing Block Universe Theory
I have often wondered about two questions, regarding time:
(1) Why is there a distinction between past, present and future?
(2) Why does time flows?
The philosopher CD Broad suggested that the universe is like a growing block of spacetime. It starts out as a very small block and then grows larger, as time moves on. Each passing moment is a new layer of spacetime that accumulates on the top surface of the block. This can be summarised as follows:
(1) The past exists (as the block of spacetime)
(2) The present is coming into existence
(3) The future does not exist (yet)
Each block of spacetime obeys the equations of general relativity (GR). However, there is an objection that viewing the top layer as the present violates the Relativity of Simultaneity, which says that the idea of a simultaneous present is not absolute, but depends on the frame of reference of the observer. For observer A, two lights may flash at the same time. For observer B (travelling at a different speed), the two lights flash at different times, perhaps 1 second apart.
Recently, I was reading "Time Reborn" by Lee Smolin, and he has a way out of this problem. He introduces the concept of preferred global time. This is time from the point of view of a stationary observer looking at the galaxies receding away, or equivalently, looking at the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). Preferred global time is related to the current size of the Universe, which, as we know, is expanding. The other frames of reference are just local and subjective, and are not as important as global time.
There is a theory called shape dynamics. This allows us to have a preferred global time for the universe. It turns out to be locally equivalent to general relativity! In shape dynamics, regions of space expand and contract but time always flows at the same rate. Time is real, rather than being a "persistent illusion" as Einstein called it.
But what about question 2 above? Why does time flow? I think it might be some kind of quantum effect which happens on the upper surface of the growing block. There is a dark energy in space which causes the universe to expand and accelerate, and distant galaxies to repel each other. The density of dark energy is uniform throughout space and constant over time. Perhaps it also causes the growing block to grow? The fact that dark energy is constant explains why preferred global time always flows at the same rate.
Also, I would suggest that as each layer of spacetime is added, the "thickness" of this layer equals the Planck time, which is about 5 x 10^-44 second. This is the smallest meaningful time interval. Below this interval, the concept of time "breaks down". It is also the natural time unit for quantum gravity. In my opinion, a theory of quantum gravity would help us to understand the Growing Block Universe theory.
Any suggestions about these questions and ideas would be very welcome...
Postscript: Recently, I came across a book called "The Oxford Handbook of the Philosophy of Time". This discusses C.D. Broad's theory in detail.
(1) Why is there a distinction between past, present and future?
(2) Why does time flows?
The philosopher CD Broad suggested that the universe is like a growing block of spacetime. It starts out as a very small block and then grows larger, as time moves on. Each passing moment is a new layer of spacetime that accumulates on the top surface of the block. This can be summarised as follows:
(1) The past exists (as the block of spacetime)
(2) The present is coming into existence
(3) The future does not exist (yet)
Each block of spacetime obeys the equations of general relativity (GR). However, there is an objection that viewing the top layer as the present violates the Relativity of Simultaneity, which says that the idea of a simultaneous present is not absolute, but depends on the frame of reference of the observer. For observer A, two lights may flash at the same time. For observer B (travelling at a different speed), the two lights flash at different times, perhaps 1 second apart.
Recently, I was reading "Time Reborn" by Lee Smolin, and he has a way out of this problem. He introduces the concept of preferred global time. This is time from the point of view of a stationary observer looking at the galaxies receding away, or equivalently, looking at the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). Preferred global time is related to the current size of the Universe, which, as we know, is expanding. The other frames of reference are just local and subjective, and are not as important as global time.
There is a theory called shape dynamics. This allows us to have a preferred global time for the universe. It turns out to be locally equivalent to general relativity! In shape dynamics, regions of space expand and contract but time always flows at the same rate. Time is real, rather than being a "persistent illusion" as Einstein called it.
But what about question 2 above? Why does time flow? I think it might be some kind of quantum effect which happens on the upper surface of the growing block. There is a dark energy in space which causes the universe to expand and accelerate, and distant galaxies to repel each other. The density of dark energy is uniform throughout space and constant over time. Perhaps it also causes the growing block to grow? The fact that dark energy is constant explains why preferred global time always flows at the same rate.
Also, I would suggest that as each layer of spacetime is added, the "thickness" of this layer equals the Planck time, which is about 5 x 10^-44 second. This is the smallest meaningful time interval. Below this interval, the concept of time "breaks down". It is also the natural time unit for quantum gravity. In my opinion, a theory of quantum gravity would help us to understand the Growing Block Universe theory.
Any suggestions about these questions and ideas would be very welcome...
Postscript: Recently, I came across a book called "The Oxford Handbook of the Philosophy of Time". This discusses C.D. Broad's theory in detail.
Wednesday, 22 January 2014
Quantum Field Theory
Recently, I have been reading about Quantum Field Theory. What happened was: a group of physicists, starting with Dirac, wanted to apply the principles of quantum mechanics to the electromagnetic field. They wanted to quantize the field. In other words, they wanted to describe it in discrete units.
You could take a classical field, such as an electric field, and at each point, there is a vector, describing the strength and direction of the field. Such a field contains infinitely many points, because space forms a continuum, similar to a real vector space with three dimensions.
The quantum field leads to some interesting conclusions: For one thing, it is possible for a pair of particles, such as an electron-positron pair to be created spontaneously in the vacuum out of pure energy. This is essentially because of a version of the uncertainty principle involving energy and time:
delta E delta t >= h / (4 pi)
The pair of particles only exists for a fraction of a second, and then they "annihilate" one another, and transform into a photon.
electron + positron --> photon
Which reminds me: The photon is the field boson associated with the EM field. Every field has its own field boson, which has integer spin. This is an excited state of the field. It corresponds to a concentration of energy in a small part of the field. Photon exchange is the cause of the force acting between charge particles. Of course, it is also a particle of light. In a hydrogen atom, when an electron falls down to a lower energy level, it releases energy in the form of a photon.
What I have described above is Quantum Electro Dynamics (QED). It is very accurate empirically, but there are mathematical problems: certain power series and integrals diverge to infinity, and a technique called renormalization has to be applied, which is essentially as follows:
infinity - infinity = x
where x is some quantity, such as the charge of an electron. Of course, this is not mathematically rigorous. The LHS of the equation is not properly defined. Also, the x could be any finite real number! We have just arbitrarily plugged in the empirical measured value. These difficulties still haunt QED.
There is another theory called Quantum Chromo Dynamics (QCD), which basically describe how a proton is made up of three quarks, held together by field bosons called gluons, because they glue things together!
I will write this some more next time! Have a nice day!
You could take a classical field, such as an electric field, and at each point, there is a vector, describing the strength and direction of the field. Such a field contains infinitely many points, because space forms a continuum, similar to a real vector space with three dimensions.
The quantum field leads to some interesting conclusions: For one thing, it is possible for a pair of particles, such as an electron-positron pair to be created spontaneously in the vacuum out of pure energy. This is essentially because of a version of the uncertainty principle involving energy and time:
delta E delta t >= h / (4 pi)
The pair of particles only exists for a fraction of a second, and then they "annihilate" one another, and transform into a photon.
electron + positron --> photon
Which reminds me: The photon is the field boson associated with the EM field. Every field has its own field boson, which has integer spin. This is an excited state of the field. It corresponds to a concentration of energy in a small part of the field. Photon exchange is the cause of the force acting between charge particles. Of course, it is also a particle of light. In a hydrogen atom, when an electron falls down to a lower energy level, it releases energy in the form of a photon.
What I have described above is Quantum Electro Dynamics (QED). It is very accurate empirically, but there are mathematical problems: certain power series and integrals diverge to infinity, and a technique called renormalization has to be applied, which is essentially as follows:
infinity - infinity = x
where x is some quantity, such as the charge of an electron. Of course, this is not mathematically rigorous. The LHS of the equation is not properly defined. Also, the x could be any finite real number! We have just arbitrarily plugged in the empirical measured value. These difficulties still haunt QED.
There is another theory called Quantum Chromo Dynamics (QCD), which basically describe how a proton is made up of three quarks, held together by field bosons called gluons, because they glue things together!
I will write this some more next time! Have a nice day!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)