It's been a very exciting few days. In the New Scientist, I read about a theory of brain functioning from Matthew Fisher. His theory is that large numbers of phosphorus atoms become entangled and start to interact with each other. Depending on its spin, each atom embodies one qubit of information. An ordinary, classical bit is either 0 or 1, but a qubit can be a combination of these, e.g.,
lambda 1 |0> + lambda 2 |1>
where lambda 1 and lambda 2 are complex numbers, and the |0> and the |1> are basis vectors for spin-up and spin-down. Together, all the qubits can embody a large amount of info. Matthew Fisher believes this is our conscious experience, eg, if I look at the outside of a house, the information about the shape and colour patterns of the house are embodied in the spin states of the phosphorus atoms, and this becomes my mental image of the house. This is one unified mental image, arising from one unified wave function.
Today, something strange occurred to me. Quantum coherence also occurs in the green leaves of plants and in the cores of neutron stars. Perhaps plants and neutron stars have some low-level form of consciousness. It's difficult for us to know, because we can't communicate with them.
Also, other researchers have been trying to build quantum computers that work at low temperatures and in vacua, but it's difficult and the most advanced calculation they have done so far is:
3 x 5 = 15
Coincidentally, 15 is the atomic number of phosphorus!
Sunday, 6 December 2015
Friday, 4 December 2015
STOP PRESS! NEW QUANTUM THEORY OF BRAIN FUNCTIONING!
Good day to you all!
In a recent edition of New Scientist, I was excited to read about Matthew Fisher's theory about how quantum mechanics is involved in brain functioning (or cognition). Basically, it involves entangled states of phosphorus atoms.
Matthew Fisher is a physicist. According to him, calcium phosphate is able to stay in a quantum coherent state for about 27 hours. A phosphorus atom has spin 1/2 in the environment of the brain, eg, cerebro-spinal fluid or cytoplasm. Phosphorus atoms become entangled due to metabolic reactions involving ADP (adenosine diphosphate, which, of course, contains phosphorus). These atoms spread across the brain. Each atom is a qubit. Its basis vectors are spin up and spin down. Superpositions of spin up and spin down correspond to points on the Riemann sphere. In theory, millions of these atoms could be entangled across the cortex of the brain. Millions of qubits could give rise to consciousness. A single coherent state explains the unity of consciousness. This is an incredible theory!
For more details, here is the original research paper:
http://arxiv.org/abs/1508.05929
I will write in more detail about this later on. For the time being, this reminds me of the Penrose / Hameroff theory, except that it has phosphorus atoms as the functional units (qubits) instead of tubulin dimers.
In a recent edition of New Scientist, I was excited to read about Matthew Fisher's theory about how quantum mechanics is involved in brain functioning (or cognition). Basically, it involves entangled states of phosphorus atoms.
Matthew Fisher is a physicist. According to him, calcium phosphate is able to stay in a quantum coherent state for about 27 hours. A phosphorus atom has spin 1/2 in the environment of the brain, eg, cerebro-spinal fluid or cytoplasm. Phosphorus atoms become entangled due to metabolic reactions involving ADP (adenosine diphosphate, which, of course, contains phosphorus). These atoms spread across the brain. Each atom is a qubit. Its basis vectors are spin up and spin down. Superpositions of spin up and spin down correspond to points on the Riemann sphere. In theory, millions of these atoms could be entangled across the cortex of the brain. Millions of qubits could give rise to consciousness. A single coherent state explains the unity of consciousness. This is an incredible theory!
For more details, here is the original research paper:
http://arxiv.org/abs/1508.05929
I will write in more detail about this later on. For the time being, this reminds me of the Penrose / Hameroff theory, except that it has phosphorus atoms as the functional units (qubits) instead of tubulin dimers.
Sunday, 13 September 2015
Socialism and Physics
Because of the recent resurgence in European Socialism, I think it is appropriate to say something about quantum mechanics and its relationship to socialism.
The motto of the 1789 Revolution was, of course: "Liberty, Equality, Fraternity". It is still the motto of the French Republic, and these are fundamental ideals of international socialism. Analogues of the three ideals may be found in the physics of a typical quantum particle, e.g., an electron...
Liberty: When an electron's wavefunction collapses, it is free to collapse into one of several different states. It does this randomly (or via the exercise of free will), not deterministically. In QM. there is the Free Will Theorem.
Equality: All electrons are so similar that they are indistinguishable. They have the same charge, rest mass, spin, etc. We can only distinguish between them on the basis of position and momentum. Thus, all electrons are equal. (Some are not any more equal than others, to avoid the Orwellian joke.)
Fraternity: In quantum mechanics, particles are not isolated from one another across the gulf of space. (By the way, space is not really empty, being filled with short-lived virtual particles.) On the contrary, they often become entangled, as in the EPR paradox. Several particles may exist in an entangled state. A striking example is a Bose-Einstein condensate, in which you have a macroscopic quantum state, on the scale of (say) 10 cm or 1 metre. One example of this might be liquid helium at a low temperature. So the atoms and particles in superfluid helium are united in solidarity and brotherhood.
Thus, socialist principles exist even at the quantum level. Given that all the atoms in our bodies are quantum particles, we have an inherent tendency towards socialism, a political ideology that does work in practice: look at how successful it has been in Norway and Sweden.
Any comments on this little essay would be most welcome!
The motto of the 1789 Revolution was, of course: "Liberty, Equality, Fraternity". It is still the motto of the French Republic, and these are fundamental ideals of international socialism. Analogues of the three ideals may be found in the physics of a typical quantum particle, e.g., an electron...
Liberty: When an electron's wavefunction collapses, it is free to collapse into one of several different states. It does this randomly (or via the exercise of free will), not deterministically. In QM. there is the Free Will Theorem.
Equality: All electrons are so similar that they are indistinguishable. They have the same charge, rest mass, spin, etc. We can only distinguish between them on the basis of position and momentum. Thus, all electrons are equal. (Some are not any more equal than others, to avoid the Orwellian joke.)
Fraternity: In quantum mechanics, particles are not isolated from one another across the gulf of space. (By the way, space is not really empty, being filled with short-lived virtual particles.) On the contrary, they often become entangled, as in the EPR paradox. Several particles may exist in an entangled state. A striking example is a Bose-Einstein condensate, in which you have a macroscopic quantum state, on the scale of (say) 10 cm or 1 metre. One example of this might be liquid helium at a low temperature. So the atoms and particles in superfluid helium are united in solidarity and brotherhood.
Thus, socialist principles exist even at the quantum level. Given that all the atoms in our bodies are quantum particles, we have an inherent tendency towards socialism, a political ideology that does work in practice: look at how successful it has been in Norway and Sweden.
Any comments on this little essay would be most welcome!
Sunday, 17 May 2015
Consciousness and Transcomputability
Perhaps some of the constants of Nature are non-computable numbers:
G = 6.673 x 10^-11 N m^2 kg^-2
c = 2.99 x 10^8 m s^-1
h = 6.626 x 10^-34 J s
It would be difficult to test experimentally whether they are non-computable. Quantities can only be measured to a small number of significant figures. QED has been tested to 10 sig fig, whereas general relativity has been tested to 14 sig fig. But we don't know what happens in the infinite number of decimal places beyond the known value.
There are solutions to the Schrodinger equation which take the form of eigenvalues. They equal the energy level of (say) an electron in a hydrogen atom. The Schrodinger eqn is:
H psi = (i * h / 2 * pi) * (d psi / dt)
pi is computable because it can be found from an infinite series:
pi = 4 arctan(1)
= sum of k = 0 to infinity ((-1)^k / (2k+1))
Also, e occurs frequently in physics equations, including some of the solutions to the Schrodinger equation, and
e = sum of k = 0 to infinity (1 / k factorial)
I am not sure whether we can really say that i (the imaginary unit) is computable! Of course, it is not a real number, so I am not sure how you would program a Turing machine to calculate it. On the other hand, its absolute value is 1, and it is the solution of the quadratic x^2 + 1 = 0.
This leaves h. Now, h is a physical constant, rather than a mathematical constant. It is measured rather than derived from first principles. Thus, h is truly fundamental. It cannot be derived from anything else, or defined. I think it is very probable that h is non-computable, because in a measure-theoretic sense, most real numbers are not computable. There are is only a countably infinite set of Turing machines, and hence only countably many computable numbers. Therefore, it you were to pick a number x completely at random from R (the set of all real numbers), it would almost certainly be non-computable. The set of computable numbers has measure zero.
Returning to the Schrodinger equation, let us assume that h is non-computable. Then we have this non-computable number as a kind of "constant of proportionality". Some solutions take the form of eigenvectors (wavefunctions) and eigenvalues (energy levels). Once again, it is very likely that each eignevalue is non-computable.
Versions of the S equation for systems with a large number of particles, eg, a large biomolecule (such as DNA, RNA, microtubule, neurotransmitter) could not be solved analytically. Either no analytical solution exists or else we humans are not clever enough to solve it.
In such situations, people resort to numerical approximations (perhaps using computers), but Nature itself makes no such approximation. The various physical values are real numbers which are probably non-computable.
In Nature, there are many physical systems that evolve dynamically, based on the interplay of mostly non-computable numbers, with a few computable numbers like e, pi, square root of 2, a/b thrown in for good measure! All physical quantities (eg, mass, energy, length, time, velocity, etc) may be described by numbers (scalars) or combinations of numbers (tensors). I would suggest the following hypothesis:
Newtonian physics is non-computable and deterministic
Quantum mechanics is non-computable and non-deterministic (the latter property making free will possible)
Thus, a system composed of conventional matter, such as the human brain operates and goes about its daily business in a non-computable way. However, this means that even a conventional computer (such as an ordinary desktop PC) is (strictly speaking) non-computable. This is true, but a PC has built-in features to "iron out" the non-computability. Each bit is either 0 or 1, obviously computable numbers. How could voltages subject to random noise be kept at strictly computable values? This could be achieved using tolerance bands:
Let x be a voltage.
If -0.1 <= x <= 0.1, then x should be flattened out to 0
If 0.9 <= x <= 1.1, then x should be flattened out to 1
Occasionally, there are random errors, due to non-computable physics, but these are interpreted as a flip between 0 and 1. This is the kind of thing that happens when a data file gets corrupted.
By contrast, the human brain (and perhaps even the eternal soul) harnesses the richness of the real number system. Furthermore, there is a hierarchy of transfinite numbers. But I shall leave it there for the moment, and say more about these transfinite numbers on subsequent blog postings.
G = 6.673 x 10^-11 N m^2 kg^-2
c = 2.99 x 10^8 m s^-1
h = 6.626 x 10^-34 J s
It would be difficult to test experimentally whether they are non-computable. Quantities can only be measured to a small number of significant figures. QED has been tested to 10 sig fig, whereas general relativity has been tested to 14 sig fig. But we don't know what happens in the infinite number of decimal places beyond the known value.
There are solutions to the Schrodinger equation which take the form of eigenvalues. They equal the energy level of (say) an electron in a hydrogen atom. The Schrodinger eqn is:
H psi = (i * h / 2 * pi) * (d psi / dt)
pi is computable because it can be found from an infinite series:
pi = 4 arctan(1)
= sum of k = 0 to infinity ((-1)^k / (2k+1))
Also, e occurs frequently in physics equations, including some of the solutions to the Schrodinger equation, and
e = sum of k = 0 to infinity (1 / k factorial)
I am not sure whether we can really say that i (the imaginary unit) is computable! Of course, it is not a real number, so I am not sure how you would program a Turing machine to calculate it. On the other hand, its absolute value is 1, and it is the solution of the quadratic x^2 + 1 = 0.
This leaves h. Now, h is a physical constant, rather than a mathematical constant. It is measured rather than derived from first principles. Thus, h is truly fundamental. It cannot be derived from anything else, or defined. I think it is very probable that h is non-computable, because in a measure-theoretic sense, most real numbers are not computable. There are is only a countably infinite set of Turing machines, and hence only countably many computable numbers. Therefore, it you were to pick a number x completely at random from R (the set of all real numbers), it would almost certainly be non-computable. The set of computable numbers has measure zero.
Returning to the Schrodinger equation, let us assume that h is non-computable. Then we have this non-computable number as a kind of "constant of proportionality". Some solutions take the form of eigenvectors (wavefunctions) and eigenvalues (energy levels). Once again, it is very likely that each eignevalue is non-computable.
Versions of the S equation for systems with a large number of particles, eg, a large biomolecule (such as DNA, RNA, microtubule, neurotransmitter) could not be solved analytically. Either no analytical solution exists or else we humans are not clever enough to solve it.
In such situations, people resort to numerical approximations (perhaps using computers), but Nature itself makes no such approximation. The various physical values are real numbers which are probably non-computable.
In Nature, there are many physical systems that evolve dynamically, based on the interplay of mostly non-computable numbers, with a few computable numbers like e, pi, square root of 2, a/b thrown in for good measure! All physical quantities (eg, mass, energy, length, time, velocity, etc) may be described by numbers (scalars) or combinations of numbers (tensors). I would suggest the following hypothesis:
Newtonian physics is non-computable and deterministic
Quantum mechanics is non-computable and non-deterministic (the latter property making free will possible)
Thus, a system composed of conventional matter, such as the human brain operates and goes about its daily business in a non-computable way. However, this means that even a conventional computer (such as an ordinary desktop PC) is (strictly speaking) non-computable. This is true, but a PC has built-in features to "iron out" the non-computability. Each bit is either 0 or 1, obviously computable numbers. How could voltages subject to random noise be kept at strictly computable values? This could be achieved using tolerance bands:
Let x be a voltage.
If -0.1 <= x <= 0.1, then x should be flattened out to 0
If 0.9 <= x <= 1.1, then x should be flattened out to 1
Occasionally, there are random errors, due to non-computable physics, but these are interpreted as a flip between 0 and 1. This is the kind of thing that happens when a data file gets corrupted.
By contrast, the human brain (and perhaps even the eternal soul) harnesses the richness of the real number system. Furthermore, there is a hierarchy of transfinite numbers. But I shall leave it there for the moment, and say more about these transfinite numbers on subsequent blog postings.
Monday, 4 May 2015
The Freudian unconscious
I have written a lot about the relationship between quantum mechanics and consciousness, but what about the unconscious mind, which is so central to Freudian psychoanalysis? I have been reading up on this, and I found an interesting website, which suggesting that the unconscious and the wavefunction of the mind are one and the same thing.
It is impossible for a physicist to observer the wavefunction directly. Every time you observer it, you cause it to collapse. Likewise, it is not possible for the psychiatrist to observer the patient's unconscious directly. Aspects of the unconscious can only be inferred indirectly from therapy sessions, word association, etc.
The conscious mind is something that emerges out of the unconscious, perhaps when a certain level of interconnectedness is reached, or perhaps when the brain waves are oscillating at exactly the right frequency. Like any other organ, the brain needs to rest sometimes. I suppose this is why it goes to sleep for periods of about 8 hours. However, during the REM phase of sleep, the brain, in a sense becomes conscious again, and the sleeper experiences strange sequences of images that we call "dreams".
Dreams are like little stories, but they do not make much sense, at least, not in terms of classical logic and cause-and-effect. They are hyperassociative, i.e., disparate ideas are interconnected. Several different people can merge together into a single "person", in a process that Freud called "condensation". In Freud's dream about Irma's injection, the dream character of Irma is the condensation of about four different people who Freud knew in waking life.
The interconnection of different persons, images and ideas is like the superposition of states in QM. (Or the entanglement of particles in the EPR paradox: Bell states.) Several things combine together to make a single wavefunction.
For more information, see this essay:
http://www.goertzel.org/dynapsyc/1998/QuantumDreams.html
It is impossible for a physicist to observer the wavefunction directly. Every time you observer it, you cause it to collapse. Likewise, it is not possible for the psychiatrist to observer the patient's unconscious directly. Aspects of the unconscious can only be inferred indirectly from therapy sessions, word association, etc.
The conscious mind is something that emerges out of the unconscious, perhaps when a certain level of interconnectedness is reached, or perhaps when the brain waves are oscillating at exactly the right frequency. Like any other organ, the brain needs to rest sometimes. I suppose this is why it goes to sleep for periods of about 8 hours. However, during the REM phase of sleep, the brain, in a sense becomes conscious again, and the sleeper experiences strange sequences of images that we call "dreams".
Dreams are like little stories, but they do not make much sense, at least, not in terms of classical logic and cause-and-effect. They are hyperassociative, i.e., disparate ideas are interconnected. Several different people can merge together into a single "person", in a process that Freud called "condensation". In Freud's dream about Irma's injection, the dream character of Irma is the condensation of about four different people who Freud knew in waking life.
The interconnection of different persons, images and ideas is like the superposition of states in QM. (Or the entanglement of particles in the EPR paradox: Bell states.) Several things combine together to make a single wavefunction.
For more information, see this essay:
http://www.goertzel.org/dynapsyc/1998/QuantumDreams.html
Tuesday, 17 March 2015
More about Quantum Biology
I have now finished reading "Life on the Edge: The Coming Age of Quantum Biology". On the whole the book is excellent. It gives some fascinating examples of how QM plays an important role in living organisms: plants, animals, bacteria. It may have a role to play in the origin of life in the primordial oceans!
In chapter 10, they start to talk about how life may be created artificially in a laboratory. This is similar to the research that Craig Venter has been carrying out over the past few years, but it would be even more extreme, because it would involve the creation of a living organism "from scratch", out of non-living raw materials, such as molecules. This would raise serious ethical dilemmas. It would be almost like "playing God". Basically, I am very much opposed to this. But the authors are not necessarily advocating this. They are just saying that it's a possibility.
The recurring examples of quantum biology seem to be:
tunnelling of electrons and protons across a potential barrier
superposition of states (e.g., path of an exciton through a green leaf, in photosynthesis)
entanglement of particles (a kind of EPR effect)
vibrational frequencies between atoms (e.g., in olfactory molecules)
It talks of coherence and decoherence. If I am not mistaken, they use "decoherence" to mean the collapse of the wave function, which causes the entanglement and coherence to break down, at least temporarily.
In Chapter 10 (which is the final chapter), it brings all the various ideas together, and summarises them. It talks of three levels of organisation. Each level is dominated by a different kind of physics:
Level 1: Newtonian physics (everyday, macroscropic level)
Level 2: Thermodynamics (the level of large numbers of jostling molecules)
Level 3: Quantum mechanics (unitary evolution of particles, according to the Schrödinger equation)
In most living organisms, there is much interaction between these three levels, and the authors make the extraordinary suggestion that it is only because of these interactions that life is possible! Without QM, there would be no stable life! In other words, life gains its stability from the highly ordered level 3. In spite of what you may have heard, the Schrödinger equation is actually deterministic. It just deals with complex numbers, rather than real ones...
Anyway, this book is excellent, and I would recommend everyone in the entire world to read it straight away!
In chapter 10, they start to talk about how life may be created artificially in a laboratory. This is similar to the research that Craig Venter has been carrying out over the past few years, but it would be even more extreme, because it would involve the creation of a living organism "from scratch", out of non-living raw materials, such as molecules. This would raise serious ethical dilemmas. It would be almost like "playing God". Basically, I am very much opposed to this. But the authors are not necessarily advocating this. They are just saying that it's a possibility.
The recurring examples of quantum biology seem to be:
tunnelling of electrons and protons across a potential barrier
superposition of states (e.g., path of an exciton through a green leaf, in photosynthesis)
entanglement of particles (a kind of EPR effect)
vibrational frequencies between atoms (e.g., in olfactory molecules)
It talks of coherence and decoherence. If I am not mistaken, they use "decoherence" to mean the collapse of the wave function, which causes the entanglement and coherence to break down, at least temporarily.
In Chapter 10 (which is the final chapter), it brings all the various ideas together, and summarises them. It talks of three levels of organisation. Each level is dominated by a different kind of physics:
Level 1: Newtonian physics (everyday, macroscropic level)
Level 2: Thermodynamics (the level of large numbers of jostling molecules)
Level 3: Quantum mechanics (unitary evolution of particles, according to the Schrödinger equation)
In most living organisms, there is much interaction between these three levels, and the authors make the extraordinary suggestion that it is only because of these interactions that life is possible! Without QM, there would be no stable life! In other words, life gains its stability from the highly ordered level 3. In spite of what you may have heard, the Schrödinger equation is actually deterministic. It just deals with complex numbers, rather than real ones...
Anyway, this book is excellent, and I would recommend everyone in the entire world to read it straight away!
Tuesday, 10 March 2015
A quick thought on consciousness
I have been reading more of the book by Jim Al-Khalili and McFadden. A thought occurred to me: Perhaps consciousness is the situation where the micro tubules of the brain are entangled with objects in the external environment, eg, chair, table, tree. By being entangled with the environment, the human mind becomes one with it. "No man is an island," as John Donne, metaphysical poet, once said.
Just a little thought! Any comments are most welcome.
Just a little thought! Any comments are most welcome.
Sunday, 8 February 2015
QM and Banach Tarski paradox
If you accept the Zermelo Fraenkel axioms with the axiom of choice (ZFC), then it leads to a very strange paradox, namely that you can take a geometrical sphere, cut it up into several pieces and rearrange them to give two spheres, each of the same volume. The pieces would be point sets which are not measurable within any standard measure, such as Lebesgue measure. This kind of thing does not happen in our everyday experience, because we live at the classical, Newtonian level.
However, similar things happen at the quantum level. For example, a photon may be moving along, and there is a small probability that it will change into an electron/positron pair, which will then change back into a photon after a very short time. So one particle has changed into two. Strictly speaking, the particles are not really spherical, but if I am not mistaken, the Banach Tarski paradox may be extended to other geometrical objects in 3 space.
So, in conclusion, the creation and annihilation of particles at the quantum level may perhaps have something to do with set theory and the Banach-Tarski paradox.
Sunday, 11 January 2015
Life on the Edge: The Coming Age of Quantum Biology
I have now managed to obtain a copy of the book by Jim Al-Khalili and Johnjoe McFadden. Understandably, it goes into more details than the TV documentary. I am about halfway through the book. It's fascinating. So far, I have read about: a discussion of Schroedinger's original ideas about Life in which he contrasted QM (at the microscopic level) with thermodynamics (at the classical level). He talked about the interplay of Order and Chaos.
Also, the book talks in detail about the action of enzymes, especially on proteins, and how this action is greatly sped up by quantum tunnelling. The authors giving the charming example of how a tadpole turns into a frog. It loses its tail in the process.
The next chapter talks about photosynthesis in the leaves of green plants. Interestingly, it gives an estimate of the "decoherence time" as roughly 1 picosecond. There is a quasiparticle called an "exciton" which consists of an electron and a hole (the gap left when an electron leaves an atom). The exciton traverses many paths simultaneously, in order to find the quickest path to a molecule, possibly ADP (adenosyne triphosphate). Using the classical approach, this could only be done in exponential time, but thanks to quantum parallelism, it can be done in polynomial time. I find the connections with Critical Path Analysis most fascinating.
The following chapter talks about the sense of smell, which is transmitted by olfactory molecules. There is a special membrane in the nose, containing olfactory neurons that distinguish the different molecules, not by shape, but by the vibrational frequency of the constituent atoms. In fact, molecules will very similar shapes can have completely different smells. Moreoever, some molecules with totally different shapes can smell almost exactly the same. The nose "hears" the frequency of the atom, thanks to QM.
In the chapter on the Mind, there is a discussion of the Penrose/Hameroff theory. Unfortunately, Jim Al-Khalili and Mr McFadden pretty much reject this theory! Their basic reason is that the quantum coherence of the microtubules across regions of the cerebral cortex would supposedly decohere too quickly. They cite the infamous paper by Max Tegmark. However, Hameroff has already refuted the mistakes in this paper. Basically, Tegmark oversimplifies the structure of the microtubules, by saying they are linear, when they are actually cylindrical. The structure of the microtubule protects it from decoherence. So does the "ordered water" surrounding it.
They slightly mispresent Penrose's ideas. According to them, Penrose has said that the brain (and each microtubule) is a quantum computer. However, in terms of its ability to answer mathematical questions a quantum computer is only equivalent to a Turing machine (and therefore, it would not be able to perceive the truth of a Goedel sentence). In fact, Penrose has claimed that the mind is a non-computable quantum system, harnessing some non-computable physics which has not yet been discovered. He has claimed this will be embodied in the correct version of quantum gravity. When the wavefunction collapses (decoheres), it does so according to QM (Quantum Gravity), which is based on non-computable mathematics. Each such collapse is a conscious event.
Also, they say that a computer would be able to generate a statement whose truth could not be ascertained by a human. This is completely and totally wrong! A computer works by an algorithm, which can be translated into a formal system F and then its Goedel sentence G(F) can be generated, and the human would indeed be able to perceive the truth of G(F).
These are very subtle points, but it's a shame that Penrose and Hameroff were not properly represented.
Apart from this, the "Life on the Edge Book" by Al-Khalili and McFadden is excellent, and I really admire what they have done. I hope there is a lot more research into the brand new field of Quantum Biology. Who knows what more strange discoveries will be made in the future?
Postscript: I have just remembered something important: Some empirical evidence for the Penrose/Hameroff theory has been discovered in 2013/2014. The experiments were carried out in Japan, by a team of researchers. There is indeed quantum coherence in microtubules, even at body temperature.
Postscript 2: I have read some more of "Life on the Edge", which (on the whole) is excellent. The chapter about the sense of smell is interesting. Some olfactory molecules are mirror images of each other, but smell completely different. As far as I know, there is no theory explaining this, as yet. However, for other olfactory molecules, it comes down to the vibration frequency of the bonds between atoms, such as hydrogen-sulphur. Putting the different frequencies into order, this give a kind of "spectrum" of frequencies. Different bands correspond to different smells.
Also, the book talks in detail about the action of enzymes, especially on proteins, and how this action is greatly sped up by quantum tunnelling. The authors giving the charming example of how a tadpole turns into a frog. It loses its tail in the process.
The next chapter talks about photosynthesis in the leaves of green plants. Interestingly, it gives an estimate of the "decoherence time" as roughly 1 picosecond. There is a quasiparticle called an "exciton" which consists of an electron and a hole (the gap left when an electron leaves an atom). The exciton traverses many paths simultaneously, in order to find the quickest path to a molecule, possibly ADP (adenosyne triphosphate). Using the classical approach, this could only be done in exponential time, but thanks to quantum parallelism, it can be done in polynomial time. I find the connections with Critical Path Analysis most fascinating.
The following chapter talks about the sense of smell, which is transmitted by olfactory molecules. There is a special membrane in the nose, containing olfactory neurons that distinguish the different molecules, not by shape, but by the vibrational frequency of the constituent atoms. In fact, molecules will very similar shapes can have completely different smells. Moreoever, some molecules with totally different shapes can smell almost exactly the same. The nose "hears" the frequency of the atom, thanks to QM.
In the chapter on the Mind, there is a discussion of the Penrose/Hameroff theory. Unfortunately, Jim Al-Khalili and Mr McFadden pretty much reject this theory! Their basic reason is that the quantum coherence of the microtubules across regions of the cerebral cortex would supposedly decohere too quickly. They cite the infamous paper by Max Tegmark. However, Hameroff has already refuted the mistakes in this paper. Basically, Tegmark oversimplifies the structure of the microtubules, by saying they are linear, when they are actually cylindrical. The structure of the microtubule protects it from decoherence. So does the "ordered water" surrounding it.
They slightly mispresent Penrose's ideas. According to them, Penrose has said that the brain (and each microtubule) is a quantum computer. However, in terms of its ability to answer mathematical questions a quantum computer is only equivalent to a Turing machine (and therefore, it would not be able to perceive the truth of a Goedel sentence). In fact, Penrose has claimed that the mind is a non-computable quantum system, harnessing some non-computable physics which has not yet been discovered. He has claimed this will be embodied in the correct version of quantum gravity. When the wavefunction collapses (decoheres), it does so according to QM (Quantum Gravity), which is based on non-computable mathematics. Each such collapse is a conscious event.
Also, they say that a computer would be able to generate a statement whose truth could not be ascertained by a human. This is completely and totally wrong! A computer works by an algorithm, which can be translated into a formal system F and then its Goedel sentence G(F) can be generated, and the human would indeed be able to perceive the truth of G(F).
These are very subtle points, but it's a shame that Penrose and Hameroff were not properly represented.
Apart from this, the "Life on the Edge Book" by Al-Khalili and McFadden is excellent, and I really admire what they have done. I hope there is a lot more research into the brand new field of Quantum Biology. Who knows what more strange discoveries will be made in the future?
Postscript: I have just remembered something important: Some empirical evidence for the Penrose/Hameroff theory has been discovered in 2013/2014. The experiments were carried out in Japan, by a team of researchers. There is indeed quantum coherence in microtubules, even at body temperature.
Postscript 2: I have read some more of "Life on the Edge", which (on the whole) is excellent. The chapter about the sense of smell is interesting. Some olfactory molecules are mirror images of each other, but smell completely different. As far as I know, there is no theory explaining this, as yet. However, for other olfactory molecules, it comes down to the vibration frequency of the bonds between atoms, such as hydrogen-sulphur. Putting the different frequencies into order, this give a kind of "spectrum" of frequencies. Different bands correspond to different smells.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)