I have often wondered about two questions, regarding time:
(1) Why is there a distinction between past, present and future?
(2) Why does time flows?
The philosopher CD Broad suggested that the universe is like a growing block of spacetime. It starts out as a very small block and then grows larger, as time moves on. Each passing moment is a new layer of spacetime that accumulates on the top surface of the block. This can be summarised as follows:
(1) The past exists (as the block of spacetime)
(2) The present is coming into existence
(3) The future does not exist (yet)
Each block of spacetime obeys the equations of general relativity (GR). However, there is an objection that viewing the top layer as the present violates the Relativity of Simultaneity, which says that the idea of a simultaneous present is not absolute, but depends on the frame of reference of the observer. For observer A, two lights may flash at the same time. For observer B (travelling at a different speed), the two lights flash at different times, perhaps 1 second apart.
Recently, I was reading "Time Reborn" by Lee Smolin, and he has a way out of this problem. He introduces the concept of preferred global time. This is time from the point of view of a stationary observer looking at the galaxies receding away, or equivalently, looking at the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB). Preferred global time is related to the current size of the Universe, which, as we know, is expanding. The other frames of reference are just local and subjective, and are not as important as global time.
There is a theory called shape dynamics. This allows us to have a preferred global time for the universe. It turns out to be locally equivalent to general relativity! In shape dynamics, regions of space expand and contract but time always flows at the same rate. Time is real, rather than being a "persistent illusion" as Einstein called it.
But what about question 2 above? Why does time flow? I think it might be some kind of quantum effect which happens on the upper surface of the growing block. There is a dark energy in space which causes the universe to expand and accelerate, and distant galaxies to repel each other. The density of dark energy is uniform throughout space and constant over time. Perhaps it also causes the growing block to grow? The fact that dark energy is constant explains why preferred global time always flows at the same rate.
Also, I would suggest that as each layer of spacetime is added, the "thickness" of this layer equals the Planck time, which is about 5 x 10^-44 second. This is the smallest meaningful time interval. Below this interval, the concept of time "breaks down". It is also the natural time unit for quantum gravity. In my opinion, a theory of quantum gravity would help us to understand the Growing Block Universe theory.
Any suggestions about these questions and ideas would be very welcome...
Postscript: Recently, I came across a book called "The Oxford Handbook of the Philosophy of Time". This discusses C.D. Broad's theory in detail.
Testing 123
ReplyDelete