How are we able to perceive the truth of the Godel statement S, which says "Statement S cannot be proved within formal system F"? F is a formal system sufficiently advanced to incorporate the laws of arithmetic, such as the Zermelo-Fraenkel axioms or the Peano axioms.
The formal system is unable to prove it. A Turing machine could not prove it. So how are we able to perceive that it is true? We are able to look at the formal system from the outside, in a "metalinguistic" sense.
According to the Penrose-Hameroff theory, the mind is a quantum phenomenon, involving large-scale coherence of microtubules across the entire brain. How is this mind able to perceive the truth of statement S?
Let us consider the more general question of how it can perceive the truth of any statement. It holds an image of the statement in its mind. It considers whether the statement is grammatically correct, and if so, whether it is meaningful, and if so, whether it is true or false. A statement only has meaning within the context of a language or metalanguage. This could be a natural language such as English, or the abstract language of mathematics.
For a person to understand the meaning of a statement, he must relate the statement to his knowledge of the grammar and vocabulary of the language, which he must remember. Where in his mind does he remember all this? I would suggest that he remembers it in the microtubules. Each tubulin dimer can be in one of two basic states, but also in a superposition of states. I think this is how memories are stored in the brain. In this case, the memories are the knowledge of the grammar and vocabulary of the language, and also our concept of syntax, semantics and truth/falsity.
When a person thinks about a statement, all the microtubules in his brain are in a quantum coherent state, the Bose-Einstein condensate. This state can be described by a single wavefunction, and all the memories and ideas in the different microtubules come together into a single conscious experience. In this state, the person is able to perceive the statement within the context of the language, and ascertain its grammatical correctness, meaning and truth value (which could be true, false or meaningless). In the Godel statement S (above), he is able to perceive that it is true.
Only a quantum system can do this, because it can combine all this individual states together into a single coherent whole. This is called holism.
In a classical system, such as the mechanism as a clock, the constituent parts are separated out from each other, and only interact crudely via cause-and-effect (as opposed to the acausality inherent in quantum mechanics.) Any information stored in a clockwork mechanism always remains separated from the other information, and there is no possibility of combining all this information together.
This is how a person is able to perceive the truth of the Godel statement above. Anyone has the potential to do this if he or she tries hard enough, and I would encourage everyone reading this to get hold of two books by Roger Penrose: Emperor's New Mind and Shadows of the Mind, which explain the meaning of formal systems and Godel's two incompleteness theorems in more detail than I have given here.
No comments:
Post a Comment